The poster’s tagline says “All bets are off”. If they only knew how RIGHT they were…
When one creates a film based on previously written work, transferring between two different mediums is hard, and staying true to the nature of the original work is tricky. Books (which give the author the advantage of omniscient viewpoint) are a world apart from movies and television, which have to rely on telling the story visually. How do you retell a novel onscreen without diminishing with the writer originally had in mind? How do you show the written word the way it was meant to be seen? It’s a difficult task, but a lot of people have pulled it off.
Unfortunately, in the case of videogames I can’t come up with a single example where anyone ever, ever got it right. Oh sure, they’ve tried, and in some instances almost made it. Regardless, game-based movies have always been a stigma on the world of cinema. No matter how much effort is put in, the end result always comes out wrong.
When comparing the two Resident Evil films that are already out, I’d call the first one the ‘best’. It was lousy, but writer/director Paul W.S. Anderson used original characters and situations so viewers couldn’t claim they’d already ‘seen’ the ending. Other than lots of zombies and flying bullets, it was the only thing appealing about that movie.
Then he wrote Resident Evil: Apocalypse and pissed away his one good idea. Not only did he cram as many characters from the video games as he could, he introduced them all in the cheapest, most cliché action-heroy ways imaginable. He gave the sole surviving heroine of the first movie amazing superpowers (hey, they’re dating in real life) and made her even more powerful at the end. (oops, did I spoil it?). And he rounded out the cast by breaking a cardinal rule of decent storytelling: throwing in a wise-cracking goofy black man. Wow.
Resident Evil: Extinction will hit theaters everywhere on Friday. I can’t reveal specific details about it (I haven’t attended any pre-screenings) but I do know a few things offhand. First of all, it’s not going to be very good. That’s pretty much common sense. Second, it’s going to include Claire Redfield and Albert Wesker, two more characters from the game series. Oh, wonderful. Are they going to show up in the same manner that Jill Vallentine and Carlos Olivera did in Apocalypse, bursting onto the scene wielding two pistols and blasting away at zombies?
Or maybe I’m wrong in thinking Extinction will be another asstastic game-based time waster. Perhaps it will end up being the greatest movie of the year, hailed by critics as the action/horror event that forever changed the face of moviemaking. Maybe it will inspire others to create videogame films that remain true to the source material while allowing creativity to shine.
Nothing’s impossible!