Last night marked the end of “South Park’s” 10th season. Ever since middle school, tuning in every Wednesday night to has been a weekly ritiual, and to date, I’ve seen every single one.
But the show has definitely gone downhill. It hasn’t quite reached rock bottom, to the point where I refuse to tune in and watch new installments (see: “The Simpsons”) but the lack of quality is distinctly noticeable. Especially now. This has less to do with my own maturity, and much more with the age of the show itself. Once a certain point is reached, any show, regardless of how good it may have been in its prime, loses the shine it once had. That, and I firmly believe that Trey and Matt are ready to move on.
Still, there were some good moments, which has why I keep tuning in. Since the beginning, “South Park” has always been a mixed bag, so if one episode bombed out there was a chance that the next one would be better. In the later seasons, a pattern began emerging where every other episode was decent and the others were crap. But this time around, quality was not as predictable.
Today, I’m going to sort out the highs from the lows and briefly talk about what I felt were this season’s strongest (and weakest) points.
THE GOOD:
The Return of Chef!- Prior to season 10’s premiering, Issac Hayes (allegedly) made a shocking announcement. He wasn’t happy with season nine’s take on Scientology, and decided to walk out on the show. This did not sit well with the show’s creators. So the opening episode ripped on the religion in a more indirect way, turned one of the most beloved characters into a pedophile, and then killed him off. Horribly. Not content with the anger and spite expressed toward Hayes’s desertion, Matt and Trey brought Chef back at the end in a life-support suit; but whether or not his character will ever return is a question that remains to be answered.
Cartoon Wars (2 parts)- The big miss that was “Smug Alert” left more than a few people unhappy with the way the show was heading (including yours truly), so “Cartoon Wars” was a satisfying turnaround. Two-part episodes are generally better than others, and this was a good example of M & T declaring their hate for something but still being able to remain funny. They even took the opportunity to make fun of themselves for getting too preachy– though I wish they’d realized that their social commentary really is bothersome.
Tsst- “Tsst” ended the first half of this season, and it picked up the pace after two previous tremendous letdowns. It goes to show that the guys really haven’t lost their touch, their talent restrained only by laziness and apathy.
Make Love, Not Warcraft- It seems that a few people were inspired by “Red vs. Blue” over the five-month hiatus. Brilliant, hilarious, and with perfect timing, this is how”South Park” should always be. It was entertaining even for a guy like me, who has never actually played World of Warcraft, let alone watched anybody else.
Hell on Earth 2006- One of the things that the CAPalert guy hated about South Park: Bigger, Longer & Uncut was the portrayal of Satan as a nice guy at heart, and I think M & T caught word of that resentment. The character has been like that ever since. After all, what’s more infuriating to the Religious Right than the archenemy of God being the one who earns the most sympathy at the end? “Hell on Earth 2006″ continues that tradition, and saves plenty of room for humor… including a too-soon Steve Irwin joke.
THE ‘ALRIGHT’:
Miss Teacher Bangs a Boy- Teacher-student sex scandals have always been rampant in the media, long before “South Park” ever hit the airwaves. I’m not sure why it was necessary to do an episode about it this late in the series, but here you go. It did a fair job of mocking the double-standard attitudes toward underage relationships with teachers, even if the decision to use Ike as the male half was a bit… okay, it was really disturbing.
Stanley’s Cup- This was last night’s episode, and over its course the quality dropped. It had the potential to be a classic, and in the first act I was laughing harder than I’m used to when viewing latter-day “South Park”. But by the end it had shifted into a lame parody of underdog movies. Kudos to the guys for sticking to their guns and avoiding a happy ending, but as a whole “Stanley’s Cup” could have been much better.
AND THE REST:
Smug Alert- M & T have always been opposed to the liberal ‘protect the earth’ bandwagon, and it definitely shows here. The overall message– that people who choose to drive hybrid cars have smug attitudes– is stupid and misguided, but gets worse with the addition of confusing resolution.
A Million Little Fibers- Whereas all the other ‘bad’ episodes of the season fail because of their preachiness, “A Million Little Fibers” features another common occurrence: beating a gag to death. Having Oprah’s genitals argue with each other with British accents was funny during the first five minutes, but as the episode dragged on it happened again. And again. And again. It eventually got so redundant that I couldn’t stand it anymore. This had to be the worst they could do…
ManBearPig- … But little did I know what horror awaited me a week later. “ManBearPig” is the worst episode in the show’s history, hands down. Not even “Jakovasaurs” came close to this level of absolute banality. Pure crap, from beginning to miserable end. It nearly brought the entirety of season 10 down to its level.
Go God Go (2 parts)- I mentioned previously that two part episodes are usually good. I wish the same could be said in this case. Both segments were mediocre in their own way, but it was part 2 (or “Part XII”) that was the worst of the batch.
I seriously doubt that M & T are going to pay attention to the rantings in some random nerd’s blog. But I think they could learn a lesson or two from season 10’s offerings: the best episodes are the ones that rely much more heavily on jokes than messages. Good jokes, at that.
* 1/2 out of ****.